Google+
Showing posts with label csr. Show all posts
Showing posts with label csr. Show all posts

Monday, June 02, 2008

Reforming European business instead of voluntary CSR

Brussels, May 29 - Disappointed by the Commission's inaction and focus on voluntary actions in the field of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), European NGOs and national coalitions working on corporate accountability decided in 2005 to launch the European Coalition for Corporate Justice (ECCJ).

ECCJ aims to promote an ethical regulatory framework for European business, wherever in the world that business may operate. Now, three years later, ECCJ with the PSE (Socialist Group in the European Parliament) held a conference on 'Smart regulation: Legislative opportunities for the EU to improve corporate accountability' (agenda). The aim was to present three concrete legislative proposals that could close the regulatory gap and create a level playing field.
Noreena Hertz, author of 'The Silent Takeover' and 'The Debt Threat', gave a very optimistic introduction to the day. She stressed the increased forces pressuring for change: more consumers buy fair trade, more investors value environmental standards. "History has shown us that most of the calls have been heard", Hertz explained, referring to the abolition of slavery or the mainstreaming of the green movement. "There are precedents, and the timing is good." she continued, referring to the window of opportunity opening with the appointment of a new Commission next year. "Together we can create a new global order! Together, we can change the course of history!"
The first and most ambitious proposal, Extending Parent Company Liability, suggests that parent companies should be held liable for for any environmental and human rights violations caused by their subsidiaries and contractors. As lawyer David Chivers explained, the extension of the EU law to non-EU companies that have a direct or indirect presence in the EU is necessary to avoid unfair competition. Lee Swepston, former ILO Senior Advisor on Human Rights, added that higher costs are not an argument. "In former times, business also argued that limiting child labour to 12 hours per day will ruin business. And it didn't!" Raül Romeva i Rueda, MEP for the European Greens, closed arguing that we "should not care about how realistic the proposal is, but how real it is." We should fight for the proposal which should be real one day, and not for the one which is most realistic.
Olivier de Schutter, recently appointed UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food, presented the second ECCJ proposal, the Duty of Care. According to the proposal, companies should take reasonable steps to identify and prevent human rights or environmental abuses within their sphere of responsibility. If the parent company does not take all reasonable steps, it can be held legally liable. De Schutter did not conceal the problems of the proposal, for example that the Duty of Care could be interpreted as the imposition of Northern standards on Southern countries. Moreover, the question of remedies remains. The aim is to push Northern companies to support their partners with technical and financial support, building up local capacities to comply with the social and environmental standards, instead of cutting relations. Kate MacDonald from the London School of Economics strongly underlined de Schutter's last point, which she called "external misalignment between power and responsibility."
The third area of legal reform, Mandatory Social and Environmental Reporting, seemed to be the most feasible proposal, because it is already practiced in eight EU Member States, including France. CEO's could be held legally liable if reporting standards are not observed. According to Filip Gregor, ECCJ lawyer, the resulting increased transparency would spur voluntary improvements. However, the risk of greenwashing, and weak comparability between reports persist. Crucial support came from Matt Christensen, Executive Director of the European Social Investment Forum. He was "very positive regarding the proposal," if it is not too much work for the directors, and if investors can find the information in one document. Inspired by Christensen, Diana Wallis, liberal MEP, already thought there are some concrete steps to realize mandatory social and environmental reporting to be seen within the window of opportunity opened by climate change, such as the UK carbon reporting.

According to its website: the ECCJ "believes that these [three] proposals would lead to a coherent and harmonised approach to business regulation, putting an end to the unfair competition caused by companies who profit from human rights and environmental abuses," says Ruth Casals, coordinator of the network. "These proposals will provide long needed justice for victims of environmental or human rights abuses by companies based in Europe."

by Birthe Paul

Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Making Public Private Partnerships work

The second session of the 3 April Development Policy Roundtable, hosted in Brussels by the Friends of Europe, saw Business, Governments and NGOs discuss ingredients of successful public private partnerships (PPP) for development. [the first session considered the role of business in development].

Amongst the discussants there was surprisingly little criticism of PPPs. Instead many listed the factors they felt had made their partnerships successful. Since participants were mainly drawn from larger international companies such as De Beers, Unilever, Cargill and Cadbury Schweppes, discussion of local public private partnerships was limited.

Andrew Bone from De Beers stressed the importance of working in partnership. He presented the partnership of his company with the government of Botswana. He pointed out that during the last 40 years of this agreement, De Beers and the government had both profited. So, for example, no-one in Botswana is today more than 15KM from a health facility. He stressed that it was important that 80% of revenues earned from Southern Africa by De Beers stay in the region.

In his experience, the two scarcest resources were political courage and the management capacity to implement Public Private Partnerships.

Lawrence Carter explained the IFC's role in advising government and the private sector on PPPs. He warned of the need to be sensitive to the political concerns of the government in the partnership. Subsidies were often needed to allow tariffs to change gradually. The injection of foreign investment would not always be popular within a country. Interestingly, bearing in mind his first statement that IFC advises both sides in the PPPs, he finished by stressing that the role of the IFC was how to involve the private sector.

The final speaker from Cargill argued that there is a need to move development efforts from subsistence farming to commercial farming through multi-stakeholder partnerships. As an example, Cargill works with the Ministry of Agriculture in Vietnam and the Dutch government on a project to grow cocoa in place of coffee in the central highlands.

Sean De Cleene of Yara emphasised three qualities needed for successful PPPs:
  • political courage;
  • management skills - although these can be developed by PPP;
  • good corporate governance and the involvement of state owned enterprises. In many countries, 70-80% of business is through state owned enterprises.
In many cases, governments have to rethink subsidies with smart subsidies for PPPs. Planning needs to include good exit strategies and pay particular attention to support for SMEs.

Design for Aids recounted the success of a PPP with H&M fashion in a campaign against AIDS in which 650 stores raised AIDS awareness using celebrities. The partnership has now broadened to include the sourcing of organic cotton T shirts from Lesotho.

Standard Chartered operates a number of public/partnerships supported by NGOs and policy groups. It found that the success factors for PPPs were:
  • Overlapping agendas
  • Designing programs together
  • Using core skills of the business
A representative of the WHO said that their PPPs had worked in the area of technology transfer, eg vaccine production, but failed where there was little political stability and country capacity.

Traidlinks was concerned that the meeting was not able to hear from any SMEs. In their view ,the key concerns are:
  • Access to finance requires a policy change in donors and governments.
  • There is still little SME assistance
  • NGO and donors pay 3-6 times what an SME can pay and so can be responsible for a brain drain from business.
by Chris Addison

Tuesday, May 20, 2008

What is business doing in development?

In April, Friends of Europe discussed the role of business in development at the second Development Policy Roundtable held in Brussels.

In the first session, three speakers - from the business sector, the European Parliament and the UN - showed the realities of business involvement in development, particularly the need to follow a structured process and to take an holistic view of the value chain when intervening in a country.

Sean De Cleene from Yara International opened by observing that we face a crisis of leadership and imagination in development. To alleviate poverty he stressed that we need to work across sectors and work together. According to De Cleene, there have been four revolutions affecting development:
  • Technology - the opportunities of mobile phones and payment technologies;
  • Markets - globalization effects;
  • Demographics - common problems facing the planet such as food security, climate change and hiv/aids;
  • Convergence - the roles of states and corporations are changing, we need to rethink the landscape and look at whole value chains, not just raw materials.
De Cleene believes we should think big. He talked about an international effort to ensure an African green revolution. He pointed out the role his own company plays in the Tanzania partnership where they look at the whole value chain essentially from field to port. While there is much partnership in small initiatives at community levels, this is often not scaled up, as brokerage organisations in countries often don't exist.

Richard Howitt of the European Parliament focused on Corporate Social Responsibility. In his experience, companies adopt CSR for two reasons: to develop future opportunity for business; and to manage their social and environment impact.In his view, each business needs to follow a 5 step plan:
  • Screen activities against Millennium Development Goals and become part of this partnership;
  • Engage more fully with different actors in development;
  • Develop products and process to meet MDGs;
  • Become a corporate citizen - add value in the country it is working in, by for example supporting the fair trade sector;
  • Take core standards such as the Kyoto protocol, the universal declaration of human rights, and the MDGs, and participate in global reporting initiative.
Christian Thomas of the UNDP pointed out that foreign direct investment is now 5 - 10 times the amount of aid to developing countries. Growth is due to business, but despite this economic growth, one third of the planet (2.7 billion people) still lives on less than 2 dollars per day.

Historically, he recounted how business has gone through three stages of involvement with development:
  1. Philanthropy: Initially businesses contributed through philanthropy. This was primarily risk-free but the business benefit was not clear. The other problem is that development initiatives take 15-20 years, whereas donations are often not sustainable over the same timescale.
  2. CSR: Here the risks are higher - some core business assets are committed with a CSR unit managing the reporting.
  3. Core business in development: This is a high risk. Here the business looks at how business contributes to MDGs. Some companies have seen the opportunity to reach untapped markets of 2.7 billion people.
In the light of this, he felt the whole development community needs a new approach. According to Thomas, business can:
  • Improve livelihoods through selling basic goods and service to poor but this does not empower them;
  • Sell economic tools, e.g. telecoms and microcredit productivity agents;
  • Buy from the poor.
The first and third options need engagement from entrepreneurs. UNDP supports these interventions by supporting entrepreneurs. He finished with the story of the business entrepreneur behind Camelbert, a dairy business working with nomadic traders in Mauritania, that has now expanded worldwide.

The following discussions highlighted the need for the Development Committee of the European Parliament to look at new instruments to support farmers, with an emphasis on production in poor countries, in particular new instruments to support small to medium enterprises (SMEs).

There was a call for businesses to adhere to international law before engaging in developing countries and concern at the level of tax avoidance in developing countries which runs at 255 billion dollars.

At the same time, a number of examples such as the Malawi Business Coalition for aids, showed that the private sector is an active partner in the sustainable delivery of a number of projects.

According to a representative of DG Development of the European Commission, business should follow three steps:
  1. Coherence - must adhere to MDGs and not undermine;
  2. Capacity building - trade at regional level;
  3. Finance - think innovative sources, remittances, climate change payments.
Ericsson, the telecoms business, was perhaps alone in saying that a partnership approach takes too long. 80% of their business expansion has been in emerging markets. Initial risk taking needs to be shared with the public sector but the private sector can then commercialize.

There was also some concrete discussion on how this group could take the issue forward, focusing around:
  • The need to consider a specific global alliance on the green revolution for Africa;
  • The need to have case studies of public private partnerships to examine best practice.
Story by Chris Addison